 |
| Posted: Sat Jul 18th, 2009 12:28 pm |
|
1st Post |
Naim Peress
Member
|
I read in the Civil War Interactive a description of Johnston as a great Civil War general. I think the facts do not bear up to this characterization. It took Lee to fix the mess during McClellan's Peninsular campaign. I also think the fall of Vicksburg was largely due to Johnston's unwillingness to relieve Pemberton. What do you think?
|
|
Back To Top
|
| Posted: Sat Jul 18th, 2009 11:03 pm |
|
2nd Post |
ole
Member
|
I wouldn't say he was the worst, but he will do until that one comes along.
Ole
|
|
Back To Top
|
| Posted: Sun Jul 19th, 2009 04:03 pm |
|
3rd Post |
| Posted: Mon Jul 20th, 2009 06:25 am |
|
4th Post |
Johan Steele
Life NRA,SUVCW # 48,Legion 352
|
He was the best CS commanding general in the West and frankly he was the best the CS had after Lee. Look at his peers in the CS, the reality IMO is that only Lee beats him out. That said I don't think the CS had a big pool of good commanding generals to choose from.
|
|
Back To Top
|
| Posted: Tue Jul 21st, 2009 11:48 am |
|
5th Post |
Naim Peress
Member
|
If you mean senior commanders, then perhaps you're right. However, there were AP Hill, Stonewall, Albert Sidney Johnston. Perhaps those guys could have been promoted before they died. These are what-ifs, of course.
|
|
Back To Top
|
| Posted: Tue Jul 21st, 2009 12:39 pm |
|
6th Post |
javal1
Grumpy Geezer
|
"....AP Hill, Stonewall, Albert Sidney Johnston. Perhaps those guys could have been promoted before they died."
What is it that ASJ did that would have earned him a promotion? Demotion I could understand, but promotion...not in my opinion.
|
|
Back To Top
|
| Posted: Tue Jul 21st, 2009 02:47 pm |
|
7th Post |
barrydancer
Member
|
Plus, Albert S. Johnston was already a full general. He couldn't really have been promoted any further. 
That being said, I think Joseph Johnston was quite good.
|
|
Back To Top
|
| Posted: Tue Jul 21st, 2009 09:04 pm |
|
8th Post |
TimK
Member
|
I hate "what ifs". I have a hard enough time keeping track of facts. The infinite possibilities caused from one action would fill up too much of what limited brain space I have.
However, contrary to what I just said, I often wonder what would have been at Shiloh and beyond had AS Johnston not taken that (possibly friendly) shot to the back of the knee. I have the feeling that he would have tightened up his role and become the general Davis thought he could be. I can only guess that he would see that the way he delegated wasn't working and taken more control of situations. Of course, I'll never know, and therefore should concentrate my thoughts on what actually happened.
Sorry to take this thread from one Johnston to another.
|
|
Back To Top
|
| Posted: Tue Jul 21st, 2009 11:22 pm |
|
9th Post |
Naim Peress
Member
|
I'd be curious to know why you feel that way. He carried out P.T. Beauregard's orders rather competantly at Shiloh and showed great personal courage when he led that charge that led to his death.
|
|
Back To Top
|
| Posted: Tue Jul 21st, 2009 11:24 pm |
|
10th Post |
| Posted: Wed Jul 22nd, 2009 12:39 am |
|
11th Post |
javal1
Grumpy Geezer
|
ASJ was not supposed to be carrying out PGB's orders. Johnston was superior - it was supposed to be the other way around. ASJ was a weak commander, more content to hand off his responsibilities to others.
|
|
Back To Top
|
| Posted: Wed Jul 22nd, 2009 12:51 am |
|
12th Post |
barrydancer
Member
|
A.S. Johnston was the commanding general at Shiloh, and for most of the Confederate west. While we can argue as to who was actually directing the campaign, it was Johnston who was technically in charge.
Javal is correct, though. I think ASJ let Beauregard overpower him. Much of ASJ's fame comes from him being fortunate enough to die in battle, while the day was still going fairly swimmingly for the Confederates. Hence the "If Johnston had lived" school of thought as to the end of the first day at Shiloh.
As for Joe Johnston, I honestly haven't studies him much. Longstreet thought he was superb, however, and that's good enough for me.  Last edited on Wed Jul 22nd, 2009 12:54 am by barrydancer
|
|
Back To Top
|
Current time is 02:13 am | |
|
|
|
