Civil War Interactive Discussion Board Home
Home Search search Menu menu Not logged in - Login | Register

Lee and His Generals: Essays in Honor of T. Harry Williams - Civil War Books - Civil War Entertainment: Books, Movies, Music & Art - Civil War Interactive Discussion Board
 Moderated by: javal1
 New Topic   Reply   Printer Friendly 
 Rate Topic 
 Posted: Thu Jul 19th, 2012 01:17 pm
   PM  Quote  Reply 
1st Post
Siege of Petersburg Fan

Joined: Sun Apr 23rd, 2006
Posts: 124

  back to top

Civil War Book Review: Lee and His Generals: Essays in Honor of T. Harry Williams

Hewitt, Lawrence Lee (ed). Schott, Thomas E. (ed). Lee and His Generals: Essays in Honor of T. Harry Williams (The University of Tennessee Press, June 15, 2012). 368 pages, illustrations, maps, bibliography, endnotes by essay, index. ISBN: 978-1-57233-850-0 $45.95 (Hardcover).

Who was Robert E. Lee’s worst corps commander during the Civil War? How has Robert E. Lee’s reputation ebbed and flowed over the last 150 years? What were Lee’s corps commanders up to after the Civil War ended? This engaging new collection of essays in honor of legendary LSU professor and Beauregard biographer T. Harry Williams answers all of those questions and more. Lee and His Generals is a worthy companion to the “Confederate Generals of the Western Theater” series.

Because this book is a collection of essays, this book review is more of a summary with some comments thrown in and broken down essay by essay. The review part follows at the end. I tend to review essay books this way to give readers an idea of whether or not the collection will be of interest to them personally.

T. Harry Williams: Pragmatic Historian by Frank J. Wetta
Wetta writes the first of two Williams essays which bookend the studies on the performances of Lee and his subordinates. He relates the story of how Williams came to prominence, his interests, his book writing career, and his teaching at LSU. Williams is best known for his “Lincoln and…” series, his biography of Louisiana Governor Huey Long, which Wetta refers to as Williams’ magnum opus, and his biography of P. G. T. Beauregard, whose papers were housed at LSU.

The Generalship of Robert E. Lee by Charles P. Roland
Roland kicks off the part of the book focusing on the generals with a detailed look at Lee’s generalship. Roland skillfully defends Lee from some undeserved criticisms, and ultimately believes Lee’s reputation as a great general is fully justified. As a layman, I felt this essay was aimed more at Roland’s colleague’s than non-professionals and felt a little out of place in a book aimed at a larger audience. It was a bit of a tougher read than any other essay in this book. I want to stress that this does not mean I found the essay boring or not of value. It was definitely an interesting read, but I had to focus more to find that value.

A “Confusion of Tongues”: The Ebb and Flow of Robert E. Lee’s Reputation since 1964 by Brian Holden Reid
Brian Holden Reid takes a look at academic and layman praise and criticism of Lee since 1964. He leads off with a discussion of Lee’s reputation up to the 1960’s and covers Charles P. Roland’s defense of Lee against what he calls the Union school of thought on the war. Reid’s dismissal of Douglas Southall Freeman and Clifford Dowdey as Lost Cause sycophants is swift, but he does find value in some of their arguments. He moves on to the 1960s school of Lee critics, led by Thomas Connelly, and picks apart Connelly’s arguments forcefully. He makes the interesting observation that the Vietnam War’s worst casualty years, 1968-69, coincide with the proliferation of Lee criticisms. Popular sentiment during this time did not look kindly on many of Lee’s qualities as a general, including boldness and a willingness to put lives on the line for the possibility, not the guarantee, of victory. Connelly’s school produced critics, especially Albert Castel, and over time, Lee’s reputation began to revive in the 1980’s. Then Alan T. Nolan’s Lee Considered was published. Reid spends a good deal of time criticizing Nolan’s effort. Nolan’s book began to swing the pendulum in the other direction again, until we are left with a post-revision view of Lee as a great general who was not without real flaws.

Lee’s Most Maligned General: “Fighting Dick” Anderson by Lawrence Lee Hewitt
Hewitt was ready to write off Dick Anderson as the worst of Lee’s corps commanders prior to starting this essay. He methodically explores Anderson’s efforts through the war, pointing out where modern historians have faulted him or praised him, mostly the former. He also makes the very good point that Lee himself often singled Anderson out for praise during the war, and ends by covering his removal from command shortly before the surrender at Appomattox Court House. This essay was probably my favorite of the bunch, and caused me to look at Richard Anderson in a new light.

Jeb Stuart, R. E. Lee, and Confederate Defeat at Gettysburg by Joseph G. Dawson III
Dawson covers Stuart’s ride and the dire consequences for the Army of Northern Virginia at Gettysburg. Although he does assign Stuart some of the blame, Robert E. Lee comes in for some criticism as well.

P. G. T. Beauregard and the Petersburg Campaign by A. Wilson Greene
Petersburg expert Greene, who rumor has it is writing a multi-volume history of the Siege of Petersburg, here closely examines Beauregard’s messages to Lee from the crossing of the James to the end of the fighting at the Second Battle of Petersburg on June 18, 1864. His interpretation of one key aspect of Beauregard’s performance differs from the traditional view. This essay’s notes section proved to be a goldmine of sources for The Siege of Petersburg Online, my site dealing with all facets of the Petersburg Campaign. I had a eureka moment when I noticed a Beauregard Petersburg article had been published in one of Peter Cozzens’ two new volumes of the Battles and Leaders Series. Long story short, I purchased both books and found literally dozens of possible new sources for Petersburg information. I’ll be blogging on that experience sometime in the near future.

Stonewall Jackson: The Christian Soldier in Life, Death, and Defeat by George C. Rable
Rable covers Jackson’s life through the obvious prism of religion, the most important aspect of life to Stonewall. He explores how Southerners sought to explain Jackson’s victories, and more importantly, how someone as pious as Jackson could be taken from them at the height of his success by God.

“The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions”: James Longstreet in War and Peace by William E. Richter
James Longstreet’s solid military performance in the Civil War was overshadowed by his bungling forays into politics and public opinion in the postbellum years. His actions so angered Jubal Early and other members of the growing Lost Cause school of thought that they lied outright to make Longstreet the scapegoat at Gettysburg. Longstreet was often his own worst enemy, writes Richter, because he lashed out early and often at his critics. He even drove Lee’s staff officers into Early’s waiting hands by publishing items somewhat critical of Lee.

Jubal Early: Confederate in the Attic by Thomas E. Schott
Schott covers Jubal Early’s postwar career as the driving force behind the Lost Cause, from his first claims of overwhelming disparity in numbers immediately following the war (for his own 1864 Valley Campaign against Sheridan, he was absolutely correct), to his determination to eliminate slavery as a possible cause of the war, to his efforts to set up the Southern Historical Society, to his lifelong attacks on ex-Confederates who had done the unimaginable and collaborated with the Yankees in postwar life. James Longstreet was his number one target. Early, true to his personality, remained bitter and angry the rest of his life, an unreconstructed Rebel to the last. Schott pulls no punches in this critical look at Early’s postbellum activities.

John B. Gordon and the “Gospel of Reconciliation” by Ralph L. Eckert
Eckert’s take on Gordon mostly covers his life after the Civil War, looking into Gordon’s lifelong mission of talking about the war as one in which both causes fought nobly and for what they believed was right. Gordon toured the country giving presentations at speaking engagements, always tweaking but never significantly altering his message of reconciliation between whites North and South. Eckert covers Gordon’s view of slavery as a cause of the war, and his standard Lost Cause response that slavery was one of many items which caused the war. Gordon’s Reminiscences of the Civil War was his lifetime of reconciliation finally captured on paper, and he died not long after finishing the book.

Williams among the Rebels: Southern Generalship in the Civil War by Roger Spiller
Roger Spiller explores how Williams, a Midwesterner by birth and values, lived in Louisiana for most of his professional teaching career. Williams did not delve into the relative merits and faults of Southern generals nearly as much as he did their Northern counterparts, but Spiller recounts the few times he did do so. Spiller also explores Williams’ reluctance to serve in the military during World War II and his seeming non-interest in picking the brains of his colleagues who had served in the military to help shape his own views.

As can be expected when a disparate group of historians is brought together in an essay collection, there is something of interest here for almost anyone interested in the Civil War. You have traditional military looks at generalship, the historiography of Lee’s reputation, the ways in which several of Lee’s generals shaped popular opinion in the postwar decades, a mini-biography of Jackson through the prism of religion, and more. Some essays focus on one battle, while others span entire careers. Some are postwar heavy or postwar specific. Others are more concerned with the war years. Some lead to favorable reappraisals, while others offer up new interpretations. Famous battle like Gettysburg make an appearance, but more obscure contests such as the Second Battle of Petersburg are also represented. Many know of Early’s postwar career as the leader of the Lost Cause school of thought, but can you tell me about John Gordon’s much more conciliatory version of the Lost Cause?

Despite these differences, the essays are alike in some ways as well. Obviously, as the sub-title implies, one purpose of this book is to honor and remember the great Civil War historian T. Harry Williams. The other main focus which ties these efforts together is their focus on Robert E. Lee and his corps commanders through the war. Only A. P. Hill and Dick Ewell did not find a place in this volume. The title Lee and His Generals is an obvious nod to Williams’ book Lincoln and His Generals. For the most part, these essays are written in such a way as to be accessible to a popular audience. The two bookend essays on Williams’ life tie everything together nicely and bring the reader back to where he or she began.

Lee and His Generals: Essays in Honor of T. Harry Williams is an excellent collection of essays on the major Southern commanders under Lee in the east, and is in many ways a companion volume to the “Confederate Generals in the Western Theater” series, also published by the University of Tennessee Press. Hewitt and Schott are to be commended for bringing together such an outstanding collection of experts in piecing together this book. The variety of topics chosen ensures this volume has something in it for everyone. This collection is not a mere rehashing of traditional views. Reappraisals as well as confirmations of earlier trains of thought against new found criticism abound. Finally, the book provides a fitting tribute to T. Harry Williams with several essays on the great historian’s life and legacy. Readers interested in the Army of Northern Virginia, postwar efforts to reshape the way American thought about the war, and any one or more of the men mentioned here will want to own this book. This collection hits a home run worthy of T. Harry Williams himself.

Note: This book has been provided gratis for the purposes of this review.

 Posted: Mon Sep 28th, 2015 03:44 am
   PM  Quote  Reply 
2nd Post

Joined: Sun Sep 27th, 2015
Posts: 51

  back to top

<P>It nike free run pas cher was ugg boots clearance extraordinary that he had coach factory outlet brought doke gabbana outlet no replica watches more nike air max 2015 than this michael kors with reebok outlet him. Why hermes handbags had longchamp uk he canada goose not ferragamo belts brought new balance shoes a michael kors lot nike store of flowers? Why had jerseys they given him hollister nothing, sac louis vuitton no louis vuitton outlet online little thing, new balance out of true religion jeans all ugg their wealth of hermes belt beauty? ugg boots clearance He prada handbags wanted intensely north face jackets to oakley sunglasses keep swarovski this longchamp handbags flower. polo ralph lauren outlet He uggs outlet was lululemon outlet canada moved louis vuitton pas cher to substitute michael kors outlet a spray burberry of honeysuckle from uggs on sale the insanity workout hedge fake rolex close longchamp at ray ban sunglasses hand. But lululemon then bottes ugg pas cher he nike free run uk remembered juicy couture outlet that that north face outlet would swarovski jewelry be infected louis vuitton canada stuff louis vuitton outlet stores for rolex watches them. He christian louboutin outlet must do doke gabbana as louboutin uk he nike air max was oakley sale told. polo ralph lauren pas cher He ugg boots walked nike trainers uk back along oakley the ralph lauren outlet track herve leger of hollister his fake oakleys car to burberry factory outlet its rolex watch beginning, sac hermes stood oakley sunglasses cheap for polo lacoste pas cher a ghd hair moment hesitating, tore ray ban uk a hermes pas cher single air max petal barbour jackets from that glowing bloom, longchamp and jimmy choo shoes then laid moncler jackets down louboutin outlet the marc jacobs rest nike air max of jordan 5 the great flower prada outlet carefully uggs outlet in the very oakley sunglasses centre wedding dresses uk of nike outlet his longchamp outlet online track. nike roshe run The petal he sac michael kors put in canada goose jackets his moncler outlet pocket. gucci bags Then asics shoes with polo outlet a mcm handbags heavy heart nike factory he went back barbour jackets slowly burberry pas cher to michael kors outlet store his true religion outlet car nike air max and cheap ugg boots stood air max beside nike air max uk it, retro jordans watching abercrombie and fitch uk that star of nike air max pas cher almost luminous red.It was michael kors evident the nike air huarache great drought cheap nike shoes was longchamp pliage still going oakley sunglasses cheap on, for the converse field air max and montre homme the michael kors canada hedges north face jackets were sunglasses outlet more air jordans parched and brown than uggs on sale he had michael kors outlet online sale ever ray ban seen michael kors outlet online sale an ralph lauren polo English uggs field michael kors outlet before. ghd straighteners Along jordan 12 the ugg soldes road lay celine bags a ugg thin cloud doudoune canada goose of north face pas cher dust that passing mulberry bags cars ray ban sunglasses continually converse pas cher renewed. ugg pas cher This michael kors old ugg boots world vans scarpe seemed to nike free pas cher him lululemon canada to be full of iphone 6 cases unlovely sights nike shoes and sounds sac guess and odours already guess pas cher half kate spade forgotten. pandora uk There celine handbags was ugg australia the sac louis vuitton pas cher honking roshe run pas cher of michael kors outlet online distant nike free cars, timberland boots the barbour jackets uk uproar michael kors outlet online of polo ralph lauren a ugg train, nike free a canada goose outlet thirsty the north face cow louis vuitton mourning karen millen uk its nike free run discomfort; coach outlet there was birkin bag the moncler irritation new balance pas cher of coach outlet store dust in his rolex replica nostrils and uggs on sale the replica watches smell canada goose outlet of replica watches sweltering jordan 1 tar; new balance outlet there ralph lauren was barbed wire michael kors purses in the hedge kate spade outlet online near longchamp handbags by louboutin outlet and along vanessa bruno pas cher the bottes ugg pas cher top of longchamp outlet the moncler jackets black barbour outlet gate, and canada goose jackets horse-dung nike factory outlet and oakley outlet scraps canada goose of juicy couture dirty jordan shoes paper longchamp at his feet. The louis vuitton outlet lovely world from beats by dre which he ralph lauren outlet had michael kors outlet canada been air max driven louis vuitton had shrunken christian louboutin now coach purses to a spot of shining gucci belts scarlet.He hollister clothing store turned eastward air max pas cher haphazard. nike roshe run uk He tory burch outlet online left the black valentino shoes gate ugg uk open behind ray ban him. marc jacobs handbags He doudoune moncler went longchamp outlet along very true religion jeans slowly for longchamp as yet he hogan had toms outlet formed no nike roshe idea louboutin shoes of uggs whither louis vuitton handbags he canada goose was michael kors outlet going. He began to think canada goose jackets that jimmy choo outlet probably in air jordan pas cher this old world gucci handbags of nike free run ours michael kors bags he was cheap jordans being louboutin sought for burberry as abercrombie a nike huarache person who nike huaraches had mont blanc pens mysteriously disappeared. tn pas cher Someone louboutin might discover him oakley pas cher and ugg boots clearance he moncler would become mac cosmetics the uggs focus babyliss of jordan future a supra shoes thousand new balance impossible nike free run questions. ugg boots That north face would nfl jerseys be very air jordan shoes tiresome canada goose and disagreeable. oakley sunglasses wholesale He had jordan 6 not moncler thought of this in Utopia. polo ralph lauren uk In michael kors outlet online sale Utopia ray ban outlet it asics running shoes had gucci seemed hollister pas cher quite coach outlet possible instyler ionic styler that he could come louis vuitton bags back into michael kors outlet earth michael kors outlet unobserved. red bottom shoes Now on michael kors pas cher earth p90x that confidence moncler seemed new jordans foolish. He ugg boots saw converse ahead of him louis vuitton the ralph lauren outlet board oakley sunglasses cheap of ugg boots a uggs outlet modest links of london uk tea-room. It michael kors outlet online occurred air jordan that louboutin he might alight louis vuitton uk there, ray ban pas cher see a nike air max newspaper, michael kors outlet ask a air force discreet sac louis vuitton question true religion jeans or hogan sito ufficiale so, jordan 3 and vans pas cher find nike air max out air jordan 11 what oakley sunglasses had swarovski crystal been links of london happening cheap oakley sunglasses to ralph lauren the ralph lauren uk world mont blanc and discount oakley sunglasses whether he nike sneakers had nike air max indeed nike free uk been christian louboutin uk missed.The road rolex replica watches itself louboutin instead nike air max uk of being tiffany jewelry the packed together pebbles michael kors outlet online and montre femme dirt nike blazer smeared with vans outlet tar with lululemon outlet online a moncler outlet surface lunette ray ban pas cher of sac lancel grit, michael kors handbags dust, timberland pas cher and christian louboutin shoes animal abercrombie and fitch excrement, louis vuitton outlet of a moncler sito ufficiale normal louis vuitton outlet English sac burberry high road, was bottes ugg apparently baseball bats made chanel handbags of nike roshe run glass, hollister clear in places as burberry sale still water hogan outlet and canada goose outlet in reebok shoes places milky cheap oakley or opalescent, ralph lauren shot with nike outlet store streaks uggs of soft michael kors colour michael kors outlet online or michael kors glittering north face outlet richly p90x workout with clouds abercrombie and fitch of embedded golden louboutin pas cher flakes. It burberry outlet was barbour perhaps north face uk twelve the north face or fifteen michael kors yards bottega veneta wide. michael kors handbags On polo ralph lauren outlet either side true religion outlet was vans shoes a band gucci outlet online of wedding dresses greensward, jordan 4 of soccer shoes a replica rolex finer hollister uk grass than barbour Mr. Barnstaple ferragamo shoes had ugg ever seen before jordans for saleoakley and he christian louboutin shoes was an ugg expert louboutin shoes and observant nike roshe mower of polo ralph lauren lawns — longchamp outlet and beyond michael kors handbags this coach outlet store online a wide border abercrombie of nike roshe flowers. Where nike trainers Mr. nike blazer pas cher Barnstaple sat air huarache agape tiffany and co in tiffany and co his nike roshe run car sac longchamp pas cher and perhaps for thirty hollister canada yards oakley sunglasses in oakley store either hermes direction lunette oakley pas cher this longchamp pas cher border was a scarpe hogan mass lacoste pas cher of hollister some louboutin unfamiliar blossom of longchamp pas cher forget-me-not ray ban blue. Then the moncler colour was longchamp bags broken by gucci outlet an uggs outlet increasing number of tall, pure michael kors outlet white spikes michael kors outlet online sale that rolex watches for sale finally ghd ousted the blue altogether toms shoes from moncler the michael kors canada bed. ghd hair straighteners On michael kors outlet online sale the cheap nfl jerseys opposite side beats headphones of soccer jerseys the p90x3 way these louis vuitton same nike air force spikes were mingled oakley vault with masses abercrombie of plants abercrombie bearing canada goose outlet seed-pods cheap oakley sunglasses equally true religion strange michael kors outlet to Mr. coach outlet Barnstaple, gucci shoes which mulberry varied through polo ralph lauren outlet a series canada goose outlet of blues and longchamp bags mauves and karen millen purples nike roshe uk to an intense uggs crimson. Beyond cheap uggs this gloriously pandora charms coloured moncler outlet foam of jordans flowers louis vuitton outlet spread air jordan retro flat meadows on coach outlet online which mulberry outlet creamy burberry outlet online cattle michael kors were grazing. Three uggs close at true religion outlet hand, a little moncler jackets startled lululemon perhaps ugg italia by jordan retro 11 Mr. converse shoes Barnstaple’s burberry sudden louboutin apparition, canada goose jackets chewed the nike air max cud cheap ugg boots outlet and regarded true religion outlet him iphone cases with michael kors uk benevolently giuseppe zanotti speculative eyes. babyliss pro They moncler had long ralph lauren pas cher horns michael kors and cheap oakley sunglasses dewlaps like the barbour uk cattle burberry handbags of South ugg boots Europe and montre pas cher India. From air jordan these abercrombie benign oakley vault creatures jordan pas cher Mr. north face outlet Barnstaple’s swarovski uk eyes lululemon outlet went to nike air max 2015 a long jordan retro line coach outlet of flame-shaped michael kors trees, nike tn pas cher to replica watches a colonnade jordan 11 of ugg outlet white nike free and gold, michael kors handbags and to michael kors outlet online a background louis vuitton handbags of moncler pas cher snow-clad mountains. canada goose pas cher A few tall, louis vuitton white longchamp clouds air max 2015 were sailing vans across longchamp outlet online a hollister sky pandora jewelry of burberry outlet dazzling jimmy choo blue. polo ralph lauren The air air max 2015 impressed Mr. doke & gabbana Barnstaple rolex watches as michael kors handbags clearance being louis vuitton astonishingly timberland clear and air max sweet.A north face jackets sharp hollister crepitation at his hermes bags back true religion jeans turned Mr. louis vuitton purses Barnstaple’s ugg pas cher attention air max round. By wedding dresses the polo lacoste side pandora charms of polo ralph lauren outlet online the nike roshe run pas cher road in ugg outlet the christian louboutin outlet direction from nike tn which moncler conceivably he had north face come uggs were cheap oakley sunglasses the kate spade outlet ruins coach handbags of ugg soldes what canada goose appeared to be a very lancel pas cher recently lancel demolished oakley vault stone house. coach bags Beside cheap sunglasses it michael kors handbags were moncler outlet two north face outlet online large mulberry handbags apple tiffany jewelry trees tory burch outlet freshly michael kors outlet online twisted uggs canada and riven, chaussures louboutin as chi flat iron if michael kors bags by canada goose uk some explosion, canada goose and mulberry uk out coach factory of ray ban sunglasses the lululemon outlet centre moncler uk of sac longchamp it came jordan xx9 a column thomas sabo uk of oakley sunglasses outlet smoke ralph lauren outlet online and thomas sabo this longchamp outlet online sound hollister clothing of hermes birkin things catching louis vuitton fire. cheap gucci And ugg outlet the kate spade handbags contorted lines of coach outlet store online these vans shattered ray ban sunglasses outlet apple trees abercrombie and fitch helped longchamp soldes Mr. Barnstaple to michael kors outlet realize christian louboutin that polo ralph lauren some air max of michael kors outlet online the flowers by uggs outlet the wayside near michael jordan shoes at hand were also oakley glasses bent down to christian louboutin one wedding dress side as pandora jewelry if ugg boots uk by the bottes ugg passage instyler of sac vanessa bruno a christian louboutin recent violent tory burch gust burberry outlet online of wind. louis vuitton outlet online Yet he had ray ban sunglasses heard prada shoes no vanessa bruno explosion nor louis vuitton felt any wind.</P> longchamp bags

 Current time is 09:13 am

UltraBB 1.17 Copyright © 2007-2008 Data 1 Systems
Page processed in 0.1898 seconds (5% database + 95% PHP). 25 queries executed.