CATSUP

Tomatoes
Salt
2 onions
1/2 spoonful ginger
2 spoonfuls powdered clove
2 spoonfuls allspice
1 tsp. black pepper

Slice the tomatoes and sprinkle them with salt. If you intend to let them stand until you have gathered several parcels, put in plenty of salt. After you have gathered all you intend to use, boil them gently an hour, strain them through a coarse sieve; slice two good-sized onions very thin for every gallon; add half a spoonful of ginger, two spoonfuls of powdered clove, two of allspice, and a teaspoonful of black pepper. Boil it twenty minutes after the spices are added. Keep it in a covered jar. This kind of catsup is specially designed to be used in soups, and stewed meats.

From The Young Housekeeper's Friend by Mrs. [M. H.] Cornelius, Boston, 1863

Comment: This is one of the earliest recipes we have found which simply used the term "catsup" for a tomato-based sauce. This was not used in the dump-it-over-the-burger-and-fries style of condiment practiced today, but rather was intended primarily as a flavoring agent to be added in one or two tablespoonful quantities to other recipes, especially soups. The amount being made here would probably last a small household for a year.

Many authors recommend putting catsups into small bottles, so that each can remain sealed until it is opened for use, rather than always refilling the little bottle from a large jug. That process allows the contents to be exposed to air, creating a potential for spoilage.

Slice your tomatoes over the bowl in which you are going to let them stand with the salt, since the whole purpose here is to gather the juice from them. As the instruction does not call for adding water during the boiling process, keep the heat very low to avoid scorching. Mrs. Cornelius does not direct us to strain again after the onions and whole spices are added, but this is an option to consider if one does not like one's catsup chunky.

Return to Recipe Index